Fractional RF Microneedling VS. CO2 Laser
Introduction
Fractional RF Microneedling, that is, fractional radio frequency microneedling technology, is a skin beauty method that combines radio frequency energy and microneedling technology. This technology is designed to deliver RF energy into the deeper layers of the skin by creating tiny channels on the surface of the skin, thereby promoting collagen production and the skin’s self-repair mechanisms.Use tiny needles to repair the skin. If your skin is a wall with exfoliated epidermis, then radio frequency microneedle is a brand new paint to repair the exfoliated epidermis.
CO2 Laser (Carbon Dioxide Laser) is a highly focused laser technology used for skin regeneration and repair. It acts on the different layers of the skin to stimulate the growth of new skin by evaporating damaged skin cells. This laser can penetrate deep into the skin. If your skin is a wall, the wall will be seriously damaged. Then the CO2 laser can repair the wall.
Fractional RF Microneedling
Working principle:
Fractional RF Microneedling is the combination of radio frequency technology and microneedling technology.
Radio frequency technology acts like a special energy transmitter that penetrates deep into the skin. This energy can stimulate the collagen inside the skin, like awakening the “spring” of the skin, making the skin firmer and more elastic.
Microneedling is like a little magic wand that gently makes many tiny holes in the skin. These micropores can help RF energy enter the skin better, like opening a small door for RF energy.
Fractional RF Microneedling uses tiny pinholes and radio frequency energy. Stimulates collagen production inside the skin, helping the skin to repair and improve itself.
The Advantages Of Fractional RF Microneedling:
| Advantages | Description |
|---|---|
| Non-Invasive | Doesn’t require surgery, reducing risks and discomfort. |
| Stimulates Collagen | Combines micro-needles and radiofrequency to boost collagen for firmer skin. |
| Versatile | Effective for various skin types and concerns like fine lines, pores, and scars. |
| Short Recovery | Minimal downtime, quick return to normal activities within a few days. |
| Customizable | Tailored treatments to address individual needs by adjusting energy and depth. |
| Short and Long-Term Effects | Yields lasting skin improvement beyond immediate results over several months. |
| Minimal Risk | Carries lower risks and complications compared to other procedures. |
| Quick Sessions | Each treatment lasts 30 minutes to 1 hour, fitting into busy schedules. |
| All Ages | Suitable for both preventive care in younger individuals and addressing wrinkles in older patients. |
| No Anesthesia Needed | Often requires only local numbing gel, eliminating the need for anesthesia. |
Skin problems suitable for Fractional RF Microneedling
| Advantages | Description |
|---|---|
| Non-Invasive | Doesn’t require surgery, reducing risks and discomfort. |
| Stimulates Collagen | Combines micro-needles and radiofrequency to boost collagen for firmer skin. |
| Versatile | Effective for various skin types and concerns like fine lines, pores, and scars. |
| Short Recovery | Minimal downtime, quick return to normal activities within a few days. |
| Customizable | Tailored treatments to address individual needs by adjusting energy and depth. |
| Short and Long-Term Effects | Yields lasting skin improvement beyond immediate results over several months. |
| Minimal Risk | Carries lower risks and complications compared to other procedures. |
| Quick Sessions | Each treatment lasts 30 minutes to 1 hour, fitting into busy schedules. |
| All Ages | Suitable for both preventive care in younger individuals and addressing wrinkles in older patients. |
| No Anesthesia Needed | Often requires only local numbing gel, eliminating the need for anesthesia. |
Fractional RF Microneedling User Experience
Kaplan Plastic Surgery Medical Center, Tel Aviv, Israel –Haim Kaplan and Lilach Kaplan
Through multiple treatments of 14 users,Each patient had 8 non-ablative treatments and 4 fractional treatments (fractional skin resurfacing and Intensif).
Methods: 14 subjects were enrolled in this study using EndyMed PRO™ platform. Each patient had 8 non-ablative treatments and 4 fractional treatments (fractional skin resurfacing and Intensif).
Results: The global aesthetic score was used to evaluate improvement. All patients had improvement in skin appearance. About 43% had excellent or very good improvement above 50%, 18% had good improvement between 25 and 50%, and the rest 39% had a mild improvement of < 25%. Downtime was minimal and no adverse effect was reported.
Conclusions: Our data show significant improvement of skin texture, skin laxity and wrinkle reduction achieved using RF treatment platform.1
CO2 Laser
Working Principle:
The working principle of CO2 laser is to use highly focused laser energy to help the skin remove damaged parts, stimulate the skin to repair itself, and finally achieve skin repair and regeneration.
The Advantages Of CO2 Laser：
| Advantage | Description |
|---|---|
| Precision Targeting | Acts as precise “agent beam,” targeting issues like wrinkles, scars, and pigment irregularities. |
| Comprehensive Restoration | Functions as an “all-in-one repair tool,” addressing various skin concerns. |
| Stimulates Regeneration | Sparks skin’s self-renewal process, promoting growth of healthier tissue. |
| Lasting Efficacy | Provides enduring improvement over time, resembling prolonged healing. |
| Wide Spectrum Treatment | Versatile, treating wrinkles, scars, pigmentation, sagging skin, and more. |
| Single or Limited Sessions | Few sessions needed for significant results, reducing frequent treatments. |
| Progressive Enhancement | Achieves ongoing enhancement for months, akin to a magical transformation. |
| Short Recovery Period | Brief downtime, most resume normal activities within a week. |
| Professional Oversight | Conducted under medical supervision to ensure safety and efficacy. |
| Personalized Treatment | Tailored to individual needs for optimized outcomes. |
| Long-Term Investment | Viewed as a sustainable investment in skin health and beauty. |
Skin Problems For Which CO2 is suitable:
| Severe Skin Issues | Description |
|---|---|
| Deep Wrinkles | CO2 Laser stimulates collagen deep in the skin, reducing deep wrinkles for a tighter appearance. |
| Acne Scars | For depressed scars, CO2 Laser removes damaged tissue, promotes new tissue growth, reducing scar depth and appearance. |
| Hyperpigmentation | CO2 Laser targets and removes areas of excess pigmentation, encouraging even skin cell growth, minimizing pigmentation issues. |
| Skin Laxity | CO2 Laser boosts collagen production, enhancing skin tightness and reducing sagging, resulting in firmer skin. |
| Complex Skin Issues | CO2 Laser addresses multiple concerns simultaneously, such as wrinkles, scars, and pigmentation, achieving comprehensive skin repair. |
| Severely Damaged Skin | For severely damaged skin like scars or sun damage, CO2 Laser deeply repairs, helping skin regenerate healthy tissue, improving overall texture. |
| Uneven Skin Texture | CO2 Laser removes damaged outer skin layers, stimulating new cell growth, refining skin texture for a smoother, softer complexion. |
| Uneven Skin Tone | CO2 Laser eradicates areas of uneven pigmentation, encouraging uniform skin cell growth, promoting a more even complexion. |
| Severe Acne and Scarring | For severe acne and deep scars, CO2 Laser eliminates damaged tissue, prompts skin regeneration, reducing scar depth and visibility. |
| Aging Skin | Targeting aging skin, CO2 Laser stimulates collagen production, enhancing elasticity, diminishing wrinkles, rejuvenating for a youthful appearance. |
User Experience
Hui Qian, Zhong Lu, Huilin Ding and many other studies found that
A total of 31 patients with facial acne scars (11 females, 20 males, Fitzpatrick skin phototypes III-IV) received 3 consecutive fractionated treatments over 6 months
Acne scarring was significantly improved in 12.9% of patients and while 38.71% reported good to fair results.2
Fractional RF Microneedling Vs. CO2
| Feature | Fractional RF Microneedling | CO2 Laser |
|---|---|---|
| Mechanism | Stimulates collagen production through micro-needles and radiofrequency energy, activating skin repair. | Uses high-energy CO2 laser beams to remove damaged skin and promote regeneration. |
| Invasiveness | Relatively low, micro-needles allow controlled depth, reducing risk of skin damage. | Relatively high, may involve longer recovery period. |
| Pain Sensation | Generally mild discomfort, often with local anesthesia. | Requires local anesthesia, potentially causing noticeable discomfort. |
| Recovery Time | Typically short, with a few days to a week for return to normal activities. | Longer, potentially requiring weeks for recovery. |
| Scope of Application | Suitable for various concerns like fine lines, pores, acne scars, etc. | Effective for severe issues like deep wrinkles, scars, and pigmentation. |
| Advantages | Stimulates collagen, versatile, and quicker recovery. | Comprehensive repair for severe issues, suited for localized and overall treatment. |
| Appropriate Cases | Suitable for maintenance, mild issues, and proactive anti-aging in younger individuals. | Appropriate for serious skin problems requiring deep repair, with certain risks. |
Fractional RF Microneedling and CO2 Laser Possible Potential Risks and Side Effects
| Potential Risks and Side Effects | Fractional RF Microneedling | CO2 Laser |
|---|---|---|
| Redness and Discomfort | Mild redness and discomfort post-treatment, typically temporary. | Significant redness and swelling, lasting days to weeks. |
| Pigmentation Irregularities | Temporary pigment changes in rare cases. | Scar formation or pigmentation irregularities in rare cases. |
| Infection and Trauma | Risk of infection or trauma if not performed by a professional. | Similar risk if not administered properly. |
| Allergic Reactions | Very rare instances of allergic reactions to treatment products. | Occasional allergic reactions to treatment materials. |
| Scarring and Discoloration | Uncommon, minimal risk of scarring or discoloration. | Slight risk of scarring or discoloration, especially with improper aftercare or sun exposure. |
| Pain and Discomfort | Mild discomfort during treatment, manageable with numbing agents. | Pain and discomfort during and after treatment, often controlled with anesthesia. |
| Recovery Period | Generally short recovery period. | Longer recovery period due to increased invasiveness. |
| Long-Term Effects | Mild to moderate long-term effects. | Pronounced and transformative long-term effects. |
How to choose
Fractional RF Microneedling:
Advantages:
- Stimulates collagen production for improved skin texture and elasticity.
- Minimal downtime and discomfort.
- Versatile for treating fine lines, mild wrinkles, and minor skin imperfections.
- Suitable for maintenance and proactive anti-aging care.
- Gradual, progressive improvement over sessions.
Suitable Applications:
- Fine lines and early signs of aging.
- Mild skin laxity and texture irregularities.
- Minor acne scars and enlarged pores.
- General skin rejuvenation and upkeep.
CO2 Laser:
Advantages:
- Powerful and comprehensive skin rejuvenation for profound improvements.
- Effective for severe concerns like deep wrinkles, scars, and pigmentation irregularities.
- Noticeable and transformative results.
- Long-lasting effects with proper care.
Suitable Applications:
- Deep wrinkles and severe signs of aging.
- Stubborn acne scars and deep pigmentation issues.
- Profound skin laxity and texture irregularities.
- Cases requiring significant and visible rejuvenation.
Keep in mind that the choice between Fractional RF Microneedling and CO2 Laser should be based on your specific skin concerns, pain tolerance, downtime availability, and long-term goals. Consulting with a skincare professional is vital to make an informed decision that aligns with your individual needs and ensures the best possible outcomes.
FAQ
What age group is suitable for Fractional RF Microneedling?
This technique is suitable for adults, particularly those aged 30 and above as skin aging signs start becoming noticeable around this age.
What is the cost of Fractional RF Microneedling?
The cost varies based on location, size of the treatment area, and the number of sessions required. Generally, each session can range from hundreds to a few thousand dollars.
How should I choose a suitable medical facility for the treatment?
Selecting an experienced physician or professional medical facility for Fractional RF Microneedling is crucial. You can inquire about the doctor’s qualifications, experience, and previous cases to ensure a safe and effective treatment.
Who might not be suitable candidates for this treatment?
Pregnant or breastfeeding women, those with severe skin inflammation, and individuals with certain medical conditions might not be suitable for this treatment.
Related Pages:
Reference Link：
- https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/14764172.2016.1228981?scroll=top&needAccess=true&role=tab ↩︎
- https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.3109/14764172.2012.699679 ↩︎